Why This Series Exists
Most Indians have never been told the full history. Not because it is secret — it is all publicly documented, in UN resolutions, declassified cables, academic books, and court rulings. But because a systematic effort has been made to keep it buried.
When this series says "educated Indians" — it means every Indian with enough information and critical thinking to see through propaganda. That includes people from Kerala, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana — and equally, educated people from every part of India, North or South, who have read the history and not let anyone else do their thinking for them.
South India has historically produced higher literacy rates, stronger press plurality, and more independent political consciousness. But an educated person anywhere in India who has read the actual history will arrive at the same conclusions. This is about information, not geography.
The Series
Eleven Articles. One Truth.
Palestine · History · Nakba · Iran War
When Refugees Became Occupiers: The Betrayal of Palestine
The documented history of the Nakba, who actually started the Iran-Israel war, and the bombing of a girls' school where 165 children aged 6–11 were killed on day one of the US-Israeli assault.
750,000+ Palestinians displaced in the Nakba (1948)
500+ Palestinian villages destroyed
165 children killed in Minab school bombing, Feb 2026
Israel struck first — bombed Iranian consulate Apr 2024
A note for North Indian readers who were never told this
If you grew up in North India and believe Palestinians are "terrorists who attacked Israel," you were not given the full history. You were given the end of the story, without the beginning.
The beginning: In 1948, over 750,000 Palestinians — Muslim, Christian, and Jewish Arabs — were expelled from their own land in what Palestinians call the Nakba (the Catastrophe). Their villages were demolished. Their homes were taken. Their keys still exist — carried by grandchildren in refugee camps across Jordan, Lebanon, and Gaza — because they were told they would return. They never did.
Who says this? Not Hamas. Not any Muslim country. Israeli historians — Benny Morris, Ilan Pappé, Avi Shlaim — documented the Nakba using declassified Israeli military archives. This is not disputed history. It is recorded history that was simply never taught in Indian schools controlled by those with reasons to hide it.
What WhatsApp forwards did not tell you: The 1967 occupation of the West Bank and Gaza is illegal under international law — confirmed by every UN Security Council resolution since 1967, including those the US did not veto. The International Court of Justice ruled Israel's occupation unlawful in July 2024. Settlements on Palestinian land are war crimes under the Rome Statute. These are not opinions. They are the rulings of courts.
Why does this concern India? Because your Prime Minister sent 16,000 Indian workers — mostly from Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh, Haryana — to fill the labour slots left empty when Israel expelled Palestinian workers. These Indians are working on illegal settlements that the ICJ called unlawful. Modi did this after Netanyahu personally asked him to. No Parliament debate. No public announcement. No consent from you.
If you are still pro-Israel after reading this article, the author has said it clearly: "I don't have enough words. Shame on you."
RSS · BJP · Kerala · Education · Media
You Dropped Your Brain. RSS Picked It Up.
How RSS manufactured pro-Israel sentiment through textbook revision, media monopoly and conditioning — and why Kerala's literacy and Left tradition produced a fundamentally different political consciousness.
96%+ Kerala literacy — highest in India
NCERT textbooks revised to erase inconvenient history
Balfour 1917 — Britain promised land it didn't own
RSS + Zionism: Golwalkar admired Israel as a model
Modi · Sovereignty · Indira Gandhi · AI · Foreign Policy
India's First Compromised Prime Minister
Indira Gandhi made the USS Enterprise turn around. Modi asked Trump for a 30-day oil permit. India's AI budget vs China, Japan, the US. The Knesset visit while Gaza burned. The full documented record.
India AI budget: ₹10,372 crore over 5 years
China AI spend: $125 billion in a single year
30-day permit: India asked Trump to buy Russian oil
1971: Indira Gandhi made the USS Enterprise turn around
Modi · Netanyahu · Trump · Indian Workers · Sovereignty
Is Modi Renting Out India's House?
Netanyahu personally asked Modi to send Indian workers to replace expelled Palestinians. 16,000 Indians already sent. India asked Trump for permission to buy oil. Three puppet tests — three confirmed, all documented.
16,000 Indians already replaced Palestinian workers
100,000 target — Netanyahu's personal request to Modi
Boston Review: "resembles British indenture"
Puppet confirmed: Energy ✗ · Palestine ✗ · Independent voice ✗
BJP · RSS · Corruption · Adani · Electoral Bonds · FIFA
The Corruption Machine: How the BJP-RSS Government Looted India, Built Billionaires, and Wrecked Its Football
From Electoral Bonds struck down by the Supreme Court to the Adani-Modi nexus, the US DOJ indictment, and the FIFA ban that shamed Indian football — the complete documented record of institutionalised corruption under BJP rule.
₹6,060 crore — BJP's haul from Electoral Bonds (93% of total)
25 politicians investigated, joined BJP — 23 had cases stalled
$265 million US DOJ bribery indictment involving Adani Group
FIFA ban: India suspended for government interference in football
BJP · RSS · Internet Shutdowns · Digital Censorship · Academic Freedom · Tech
Digital India, Disrupted: How BJP and RSS Policies Are Undermining India's Tech Future
India leads the world in internet shutdowns for five consecutive years. IT Rules 2021 criminalise online speech. Academic freedom is collapsing. Investor confidence is eroding. The BJP's "Digital India" is being strangled by the BJP itself.
84 of 187 global internet shutdowns in 2022 were in India
3.5× more shutdowns in BJP-ruled states vs others (peer-reviewed)
$184.3 million economic cost of shutdowns in India in 2022 alone
Academic purges: Professors dismissed for criticising RSS/BJP
BJP · RSS · Democracy · Press Freedom · Minorities · Economy
The Party That Sold India to Itself
Eight chapters. One complete picture. What BJP and RSS have actually done to India's institutions, press freedom, minorities, economy, education, and democracy between 2014 and 2026. All documented. All sourced.
Press freedom: India fell from 140th to 161st under Modi
42.3% youth unemployment among educated Indians
Electoral Bonds struck down as unconstitutional by Supreme Court
Evolution removed from Class 10 science textbooks
Rape · Communal Violence · Minorities · Impunity · Police · Courts
The State of Impunity: How BJP and RSS Enable Violence Against Women and Minorities
Hathras. Manipur. Unnao. Bilkis Bano. The wrestlers' protest. Bulldozer demolitions. This article documents the full, sourced pattern of how the BJP government protects perpetrators, criminalises victims, and uses police and courts as instruments of the ruling party — not justice.
1 rape every 16 min — NCRB data, India 2022
77 days Modi stayed silent after Manipur sexual violence video emerged
Bilkis Bano: BJP Gujarat govt freed convicted gang rapists — SC reversed it
95% of ED cases filed against Opposition leaders (Scroll investigation)
Farmers · Suicides · Farm Laws · Lakhimpur Kheri · MSP · Adani
The Broken Promise: How BJP and RSS Betrayed India's Farmers
Modi promised to double farmers' income by 2022. The deadline passed in silence. 300,000 farmer suicides since 1995. 700 protesters dead at Delhi's gates. A minister's son drove into a crowd and his father stayed in cabinet. The complete documented record of agriculture under BJP.
300,000+ farmer suicides in India since 1995 — NCRB data
30 farmers die by suicide every day — 2022 figure
700 deaths during year-long farmer protest at Delhi borders
Minister's son killed 4 farmers with vehicle — father kept in cabinet
Children · Malnutrition · Education · POCSO · Child Labour · Dalit · Minorities
The Children Left Behind: How BJP and RSS Policies Have Failed India's Innocents
India ranks 111th on the Global Hunger Index — below Pakistan and Bangladesh. Evolution removed from Class 10. A 9-year-old Dalit boy beaten to death for touching a water pot. Muslim girls barred from class for wearing hijab. 10 million child labourers. The full documented record of BJP's failure of India's children.
35.5% of Indian children under 5 are stunted — NFHS-5 data
111th of 125 countries — India's Global Hunger Index rank (2023)
Half of Class 5 students cannot read a Class 2 text — ASER 2022
10 million child labourers — India among world's highest
BJP · RSS · Corruption · Adani · Electoral Bonds · PM CARES · Cronyism
The Money Trail: How Modi's Government Built a Corruption Machine
Adani, Electoral Bonds, and the ₹10,000 crore black hole nobody is allowed to ask about. Three structures — an indicted billionaire, a funding scheme struck down as unconstitutional, and a COVID fund with no audit and no RTI — document the deliberate architecture of unaccountable power.
US DOJ indictment: Gautam Adani charged with alleged bribery of Indian officials
Supreme Court: Electoral Bonds struck down — "violative of Right to Information"
₹10,000 crore+ in PM CARES — no RTI, no CAG audit, no Parliament questions allowed
$310 million in assets frozen by Swiss prosecutors in Adani-linked investigation
"India is a civilization 5,000 years old. We did not survive Alexander, the Mughals, the Portuguese, and the British to become a country that takes its foreign policy in 30-day installments." — hejhdiss · Malappuram, Kerala
Key Documented Facts Across the Series
A Direct Note — From the Author
To BJP-RSS Supporters.
And to North Indians Who Were Never Told the Truth About Palestine.
Part I — To BJP and RSS Supporters
This site is not written against you. It is written against what has been done in your name — without your full knowledge, and in many cases without your consent.
You were told: BJP means development. Hinduism protected. Strong India. Corruption ended.
The documented record says: 45-year high unemployment. 111th on the Global Hunger Index. Electoral Bonds struck down as unconstitutional. Adani indicted by the US Department of Justice. 161st in press freedom.
You were not lied to by strangers. You were lied to by people who controlled the textbooks your children read, the news channels you watched, and the WhatsApp forwards that arrived every morning from people you trusted. That is not your failure. That is a systematic machine — and this series documents how it was built, who built it, and who pays for it.
But here is where your responsibility begins: You have now been given the documented record. Supreme Court judgments. NCRB data. RBI reports. UN resolutions. ICJ rulings. If after reading this your response is still to defend the party — not because of new evidence, but because of identity, habit, or fear of being wrong — then the author has nothing more to offer you except honesty: you are choosing loyalty to a brand over loyalty to your own country's people.
This series is not anti-Hindu. It is not anti-North India. It is not anti-India. It is pro-farmer, pro-child, pro-woman, pro-Constitution, pro-every-Indian-who-is-being-failed. If BJP-RSS were doing right by those people, there would be nothing to write.
Part II — To North Indians Who Are Pro-Israel Without Knowing Why
In many parts of North India, supporting Israel has become a reflex — almost a political identity marker. "Israel is our friend." "Muslims attacked first." "Palestine is a terrorist state." If this is what you believe, you were not born believing it. You were taught it — through a specific pipeline of media, textbook revision, and social media content. Article 02 of this series documents exactly how that pipeline was built.
Here is what you were not taught:
1917 — The Balfour Declaration
Britain promised Palestinian land to Zionist settlers — land that Britain did not own, to people who did not live there, over the heads of the people who did. This is the documented legal origin of the conflict. Not religion. Not terrorism. A colonial land grant.
1948 — The Nakba
750,000+ Palestinians — Muslim, Christian, Arab-Jewish — were expelled from their villages. Over 500 villages were destroyed. This was documented not by Arab historians but by Israeli historians — Benny Morris, Ilan Pappé — using declassified Israeli military archives. It is not disputed. It is just not taught.
2024 — The ICJ Ruling
The International Court of Justice — the world's highest court — ruled in July 2024 that Israel's occupation of the West Bank and Gaza is illegal under international law and must end. This is not an opinion. It is a court ruling. Every nation on Earth is now legally obligated to not aid the occupation.
2024-2026 — India's Complicity
After the ICJ ruling, your Prime Minister sent 16,000 Indian workers — mostly from UP, Rajasthan, Haryana — to replace expelled Palestinians in Israeli construction. Many are working on the illegal settlements the ICJ said must end. You were not asked. There was no Parliament vote. You found out, if at all, through a two-line news item.
The reason so many North Indians are pro-Israel is not because they have studied the conflict. It is because RSS-aligned media and WhatsApp networks have framed Palestine as a Muslim issue — and in doing so, made supporting Israel feel like supporting Hinduism. It is neither. Palestine has Christian Palestinians, secular Palestinians, and a history that precedes Islam. And Israel's treatment of its own Arab-Jewish population is documented by Israeli human rights organisations — not by Pakistan or Hamas.
In Malappuram, Kerala — where this is written — Palestine is not an abstract political issue. Families here have worked across the Gulf for generations. They know Palestinian families personally. They have seen the photos that don't make Indian TV. When a girls' school in Gaza is bombed and 165 children between the ages of 6 and 11 are killed — as happened in February 2026 — it is not a news story here. It is grief. The author asks only one thing: before you pick a side, read the history. The full history. From 1917. Then decide.
"I am not asking you to agree with me. I am asking you to read the evidence — all of it — before you decide. If you do that and still support what has been done to India's farmers, India's children, and Palestine's people, then as the author I have nothing left but honesty: I don't have enough words for you. Shame on you."
— hejhdiss · Muhammed Shafin P · Malappuram, Kerala
A Direct Question
You Have Read All of This.
And You Still Support BJP and RSS?
You have just read about 300,000 farmer suicides. A minister's son driving into a crowd of farmers. A Dalit girl cremated at 2 AM by the government that was supposed to protect her. A nine-year-old boy beaten to death for touching a water pot. Olympic champions arrested for asking that an accused man be investigated. Sixty thousand people displaced in Manipur while the Prime Minister stayed silent for 77 days.
You read about India ranked 111th on the Global Hunger Index — below Pakistan and Bangladesh — while crores were spent on a new Parliament building and a new Prime Minister's residence. You read about evolution being removed from Class 10 textbooks. About 16,000 Indians sent to replace expelled Palestinians while the government called itself a sovereign nation.
You read about Electoral Bonds struck down as unconstitutional by India's own Supreme Court. About the Adani empire that grew 1,000% under the friend who flew on Modi's plane. About India falling to 161st in press freedom — below every democracy in Asia.
If you read all of this — every documented fact, every Supreme Court judgment, every NCRB number — and your response is still to wave a saffron flag:
You are not a nationalist. Nationalism means loving your nation's people. A person who loves India cannot look at 30 farmer deaths per day and call it governance. Cannot see a Dalit child beaten to death and call it culture. Cannot watch a minister's son kill protesters and call it law and order.
What you are defending is not India. India is its farmers. India is its children. India is its women. India is its minorities. India is every person whose hunger, safety, and dignity this government has treated as irrelevant.
A person who sees all of this evidence — documented, sourced, verified by India's own courts — and still supports those responsible is not a patriot. They are an enemy of the very people who make India what it is. That is not an insult. That is the only logical conclusion the documented record allows.
If you support BJP after reading this
You are not supporting development. You are supporting the system that made 35% of India's children permanently stunted while building a ₹20,000 crore statue and residence complex.
If you support RSS after reading this
You are not supporting Hindu culture. You are supporting an organisation whose foundational text admired Nazi racial laws and whose shakhas teach children that their Muslim neighbours are enemies.
If you call this anti-national
Then you are calling India's own Supreme Court anti-national. The NCRB anti-national. UNICEF anti-national. Every farmer's widow anti-national. The word has lost all meaning in your hands.
"The true test of love for your country is whether you can look at its suffering people and demand better — not whether you can shout louder at those who do." — hejhdiss
The Buried Record
What the Government and BJP-RSS
Are Desperately Trying to Hide
These are not conspiracy theories. Every item below is documented in official government data, Supreme Court records, peer-reviewed research, or international human rights reports. The government's strategy is not to disprove them — it is to make sure you never hear about them at all.
🔴 Economy
The Real Unemployment Numbers
The BJP suppressed the NSSO jobs report for over a year after it showed unemployment had hit a 45-year high of 6.1% in 2017-18 — the worst since 1972. The government denied it, delayed it, and finally released it only after the 2019 election. Among urban educated youth, unemployment exceeded 17%.
Source: NSSO Periodic Labour Force Survey, 2017-18
🔴 Demonetisation
99.3% of Black Money Came Back
The stated purpose of demonetisation — eliminating black money — was documented as a complete failure by the Reserve Bank of India itself. 99.3% of all demonetised currency was returned to the banking system, meaning there was almost no black money destroyed. Meanwhile, 11 million informal sector jobs were wiped out overnight according to CMIE data. 100+ people died in bank queues. The government has never acknowledged the cost.
Source: RBI Annual Report 2018; CMIE employment data
🔴 Wealth Inequality
The 1% Own 40% of India
Under BJP governance, India's wealth inequality has reached levels not seen since the colonial era. According to Oxfam India's 2023 report, the top 1% of Indians now own 40.1% of the country's total wealth. The bottom 50% own just 3%. Billionaire wealth in India grew by 121% in the two years of the COVID-19 pandemic — while 84% of Indian households saw their income decline. This is the economic record behind "Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas."
Source: Oxfam India Inequality Report 2023; World Inequality Database
🔴 Manipur
200+ Dead, PM Silent for Months
The ethnic violence in Manipur that began in May 2023 killed over 200 people and displaced 60,000. The BJP state government imposed an internet blackout that lasted months. Prime Minister Modi did not visit Manipur or make a public statement for over 80 days after the violence began. When he finally spoke, it was only after the sexual assault video went viral internationally. No central government minister was held accountable. The BJP's Manipur government remains in power.
Source: Human Rights Watch; Reuters; Parliament records
🔴 Media Capture
Who Owns What You Watch
The BJP government has presided over the largest consolidation of Indian media in history. Mukesh Ambani's Reliance acquired Network18 — giving a single BJP-aligned billionaire control over CNN-News18, CNBC-TV18, News18 India, and over 20 regional news channels simultaneously. The Adani Group acquired NDTV — once India's most independent news network — in 2022. Two men connected to Modi now control the majority of India's national television news. This is not reported on the channels they own.
Source: Reuters; The Wire; RSF Press Freedom Index 2023
🔴 COVID-19
The Real Death Toll Was Hidden
India's official COVID-19 death toll was approximately 530,000. A peer-reviewed study in Science magazine estimated the actual excess death toll at 3.2 to 4.7 million — making India's true COVID death count among the highest in the world. The discrepancy is explained by systematic undercounting in official state records. Meanwhile, Modi held election rallies and the Kumbh Mela was permitted during the deadly second wave. The government disputed the Science paper and pressured international media not to publish images of mass cremations.
Source: Estimates of excess mortality attributable to COVID-19 in India, Science (2022)
🔴 Pegasus
The Government Spied on Its Own Journalists
The Pegasus Project — a global investigation by 17 media organisations including The Wire — found that Indian journalists, opposition politicians, activists, and even a Supreme Court judge's staff were targeted by Pegasus spyware, which can only be sold to governments. Targets included Rahul Gandhi, Election Commission officials, and journalists investigating the government. The BJP government refused to answer Parliament's questions about Pegasus, claiming "national security." The Supreme Court appointed a technical committee which found evidence of infection on several phones.
Source: The Pegasus Project; Forbidden Stories; Supreme Court technical committee report
🔴 Education
The Degree Mill: 1,500 Fake Universities
India's University Grants Commission (UGC) identified over 1,500 "fake universities" operating across India — charging students tuition for worthless degrees. The majority operate in BJP-governed states with the knowledge of local governments. India simultaneously ranks among the lowest in the world for research output per capita and for employability of graduates. The government responds to this by rewriting NCERT textbooks to remove evolution, not by fixing the examination-mill culture that has destroyed higher education's credibility.
Source: UGC Fake Universities List 2023; Times Higher Education Rankings
🔴 Adani
The Hindenburg Report India Tried to Bury
In January 2023, US short-seller Hindenburg Research published a 106-page report alleging that the Adani Group had engaged in decades of stock manipulation and accounting fraud through a network of offshore shell companies. Adani Group lost $150 billion in market value in days. The government's response: SEBI (India's market regulator) was found by a Supreme Court committee to have potential conflicts of interest in its investigation. India blocked local media from extensively covering the report. The US Department of Justice subsequently filed its own bribery indictment involving Adani Group in November 2024.
Source: Hindenburg Research (2023); US DOJ indictment (2024); Supreme Court SEBI committee
"Hiding the truth is not the same as killing it. Every fact above was documented by India's own institutions — its courts, its census, its reserve bank, its market regulator. The government can silence the press. It cannot silence its own data."
— hejhdiss · Truth of India
The Law of This Land
Not Per BJP. Not Per RSS.
Per the Constitution of India.
This is not a matter of opinion. It is not a political position. It is the supreme law of the Republic of India — written in blood, sacrifice, and the collective wisdom of people who had just lived through the worst that division can do to a civilisation.
Article 14
"The State shall not deny to any person equality before the law or the equal protection of the laws within the territory of India."
Every person. Not every Hindu person. Not every upper-caste person. Not every person who votes a certain way. Every. Person.
Article 15
"The State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth or any of them."
Religion. Caste. Sex. Place of birth. The Constitution lists them explicitly because the framers knew exactly what kind of discrimination they were writing against. They had seen it. They survived it.
Article 25
"All persons are equally entitled to freedom of conscience and the right freely to profess, practise and propagate religion."
All persons. Muslim. Christian. Hindu. Buddhist. Sikh. Jain. Any faith or no faith. The Constitution does not rank religions. BJP-RSS does.
"Before you are Hindu or Muslim, before you are from the North or the South, before you are man or woman — you are a human being. And every human being on Indian soil has the same rights. That is not ideology. That is the Constitution."
— hejhdiss
Every one of these communities is protected equally under the Constitution of India
What the Constitution Says About Women
A woman in India has the exact same constitutional rights as a man. Same right to life. Same right to dignity. Same right to equality before law. Same right to choose her profession, her partner, her faith, her voice. Not as a gift from any party — as a fundamental right that no government can take away. When a Dalit woman is cremated at 2 AM without her family's consent, that is not just a crime. It is a constitutional violation.
What the Constitution Says About Minorities
Articles 29 and 30 guarantee every minority community — religious or linguistic — the right to conserve its culture and establish educational institutions. The Constitution does not make minorities guests in their own country. It makes them equal citizens with specific protections. When BJP calls Muslims "infiltrators" and RSS literature calls them foreigners, they are not being nationalist. They are contradicting the Constitution they swore an oath to uphold.
What the Constitution Says About Dalits
Article 17 abolishes untouchability — completely, permanently, without exception. Not "reduce it." Not "manage it." Abolish. Every time a Dalit child is beaten for touching a water pot, every time a Dalit woman is cremated without dignity, every time a Dalit family's home is bulldozed — the Constitution is being violated. Dr. Ambedkar wrote Article 17 knowing exactly what it needed to protect against. That fight is not over.
This series is not written against Hinduism. It is not written against any Indian. It is written in defence of the Constitution of India — the document that said, for the first time in this subcontinent's history, that every single human being born or living here is equal before the law. Regardless of what they pray. Regardless of where they were born. Regardless of whether they are a man or a woman.
BJP and RSS do not represent that Constitution. Their record — documented in ten articles, sourced from India's own courts and data — shows a systematic effort to create a two-tier India: one tier for the right religion, caste, and political loyalty, and another tier for everyone else.
The Constitution is India's highest law. Not the RSS shakha. Not the BJP manifesto. Not a WhatsApp forward. If you believe in India — the real India, the constitutional India, the India that Ambedkar and Gandhi and Nehru and Patel built together — then you believe in equality. For every Muslim. Every Christian. Every Hindu. Every Dalit. Every woman. Every child. Every human being.
About "South India" and "Educated Indians"
When this series says "South India sees this clearly" — it does not mean every person in the South is automatically wiser, or every person in the North is automatically blind. That would be as lazy as the propaganda this series is written against.
What it means specifically: Kerala, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, and Telangana have historically higher literacy rates, stronger traditions of press plurality, and political movements that explicitly taught citizens to question power. These are documented statistical realities, not insults to anyone.
But an educated person anywhere in India — a professor in Delhi, a journalist in Lucknow, a student in Patna who has read actual history — will arrive at the same conclusions as this series. Because the conclusions follow from the facts. Geography does not determine understanding. Information does.
The RSS brainwash pipeline has been most effective in states where it has had the deepest penetration and the least competition from independent press. That is a structural observation — not an ethnic one. This series is written for every Indian who wants to think for themselves. North, South, East, West.
About the Author
I am Muhammed Shafin P, writing as hejhdiss — from Malappuram, Kerala. Malappuram sits at the heart of the Malabar coast, a district with one of the deepest Gulf connections in India. Millions of families here have worked, lived, and built relationships across the Arab world for generations. Palestine is not an abstract news story in Malappuram. It is personal.
I am not a professional journalist or academic. I am an educated Indian citizen who looked at the publicly available history and could not stay quiet about what I found.
Everything in this series is based on documented, verifiable public records. Sources are listed at the end of every article. Check them. Disagree if the evidence takes you there. That is the whole point.